On November 24, 2026, the Quad9 DNS resolver will stop responding to Internet users located in France, after being condemned for not having blocked illegal streaming sites. In a post published on November 17, Cloudflare denounces a decision which it believes threatens all public resolvers.
Leaving France rather than blocking, this is the decision taken by Quad9 the day after the judgment rendered on October 21, 2026.
That day, the Paris judicial court sentenced the Swiss non-profit foundation which operates the free DNS resolver 9.9.9.9 to a penalty of 1,000 euros per day for not having applied a blocking order obtained by beIN Sports. The Qatari broadcaster demanded that the service stop, until November 14, translating the domain names of sites illegally broadcasting tennis matches into IP addresses.
Assuring that it cannot reliably identify Internet users located in France, and refusing to impose on its users around the world a block decided by a French judge, the foundation announced that it would make its service unavailable in France from November 24.
Since then, an entire industry has stood up against this decision. On November 17, the Swedish company Mullvad denounced “ a system of censorship » and invited French users of its browser who have chosen Quad9 as their encrypted DNS provider to modify their settings.
The same day, Cloudflare joined this skirmish by publishing a blog post in which the American company describes this departure as “canary in the mine” and believes that “the withdrawal of a basic infrastructure service in France fundamentally harms a free and open Internet”.
For Cloudflare, the rights holders have the wrong target
For Cloudflare, blocking at the DNS level is useless. The American company, which itself operates the public resolver 1.1.1.1, recognizes that rights holders have a legitimate interest in fighting against piracy.
However, she judges that going through DNS resolvers is “the wrong approach”. She compares the resolver to a telephone directory and points out that removing the name of an illegal business from a directory “does not actually close the business”. Pirate content remains online, and the Internet user who wants to access it can bypass the blocking “in less than a minute” by changing resolver.
To this, Cloudflare adds the technical limits of such blocking, which it had already highlighted. DNS blocking targets entire domains and therefore also affects the legal content they host, without the user receiving the slightest explanation. The problem gets worse with public resolvers, which operate on a global scale, since according to Cloudflare “ a single country could dictate what content is accessible worldwide “.
“Quad9 and Cloudflare are being dragged into court precisely because we are transparent and reputable organizations”says the company, which invites rights holders to instead target the hosts of the pirated files.

DNS managers face the risk of silent failure
A game where everyone seeks to pass the hot potato to each other.
Preaching for his parish, Cloudflare also evokes the concrete effects of Quad9’s departure. In France, the Swiss resolver is used by individuals, but also by administrations, educational establishments, hospitals and energy suppliers. As the foundation does not keep any data allowing its users to be identified, it has no way of warning them. Those who have not changed resolver before November 24 will see their connection “simply stop working”, without an error message.
The American company knows it could be next. In Belgium, an order threatens Cloudflare, Google and Cisco with heavy penalties if they do not start blocking sites via their public resolvers by early January 2027. The three companies have appealed.
Cloudflare already knows well the collateral damage of the fight against sports piracy. In Spain, LaLiga has blocked thousands of IP addresses shared by Cloudflare since December 2024, on match days, which deprives millions of Internet users of perfectly legitimate sites.
All the tech news at a glance
Add Numerama to your home screen and stay connected to the future!

