Summoned before the Paris criminal court for so-called planned obsolescence practices on 24 iPhone models, Apple publicly rejects these accusations.
“We strongly dispute these unfounded allegations,” company management told ZDNET.
“At Apple, we’re always looking for new ways to provide the best possible experience for our customers, and that includes designing durable products with software updates that allow users to keep their devices longer. »
Biometric security versus the right to repair
The complaint targets serialization, a technique linking the serial number of a replacement part to the device’s motherboard. Apple justifies this restriction by confidentiality and calibration requirements. The company claims that this approach guarantees the integrity of sensitive modules, such as the TrueDepth camera or the brightness sensors managing True Tone colorimetry.
The manufacturer specifies that the use of an uncalibrated third-party component is however not deactivated by Apple. The smartphone maintains standard operation and documents the intervention history in the operating system settings.
Furthermore, to anticipate regulatory pressure and respond to criticism of the opacity of its architectures, the firm ensures that it is deploying new design standards on its recent production lines.
And to cite for example the integration of electrically uncoupling adhesives on the iPhone 16 and 17 ranges to speed up battery extraction. Or even assembly using screws instead of glue on the chassis of the new MacBook Neo.
A financial risk estimated at 5% of global turnover
Maintaining fleet longevity also relies on software support, Apple mentions. The iOS 27 operating system ensures backward compatibility up to the iPhone 11 released in 2019, Apple justifies. And this sustainability policy results, according to Apple, in a 38% drop in out-of-warranty repairs between 2015 and 2022.
The fact remains that these technical arguments will have to convince the magistrates, the pleadings being set for next June.
The HOP association criticizes Apple for maintaining artificially high repair costs within its approved network, estimating the intervention on a screen up to three times higher than the French market average.
A conviction would expose Apple to a maximum fine equivalent to 5% of its global annual revenues.
Summoned before the Paris criminal court for so-called planned obsolescence practices on 24 iPhone models, Apple publicly rejects these accusations.
“We strongly dispute these unfounded allegations,” company management told ZDNET.
“At Apple, we’re always looking for new ways to provide the best possible experience for our customers, and that includes designing durable products with software updates that allow users to keep their devices longer. »
Biometric security versus the right to repair
The complaint targets serialization, a technique linking the serial number of a replacement part to the device’s motherboard. Apple justifies this restriction by confidentiality and calibration requirements. The company claims that this approach guarantees the integrity of sensitive modules, such as the TrueDepth camera or the brightness sensors managing True Tone colorimetry.
The manufacturer specifies that the use of an uncalibrated third-party component is however not deactivated by Apple. The smartphone maintains standard operation and documents the intervention history in the operating system settings.
Furthermore, to anticipate regulatory pressure and respond to criticism of the opacity of its architectures, the firm ensures that it is deploying new design standards on its recent production lines.
And to cite for example the integration of electrically uncoupling adhesives on the iPhone 16 and 17 ranges to speed up battery extraction. Or even assembly using screws instead of glue on the chassis of the new MacBook Neo.
A financial risk estimated at 5% of global turnover
Maintaining fleet longevity also relies on software support, Apple mentions. The iOS 27 operating system ensures backward compatibility up to the iPhone 11 released in 2019, Apple justifies. And this sustainability policy results, according to Apple, in a 38% drop in out-of-warranty repairs between 2015 and 2022.
The fact remains that these technical arguments will have to convince the magistrates, the pleadings being set for next June.
The HOP association criticizes Apple for maintaining artificially high repair costs within its approved network, estimating the intervention on a screen up to three times higher than the French market average.
A conviction would expose Apple to a maximum fine equivalent to 5% of its global annual revenues.
https://www.zdnet.fr/wp-content/uploads/zdnet/2026/06/techwoven-case-and-iphone-air-bumper.webp https://www.zdnet.fr/actualites/proces-pour-obsolescence-apple-justifie-sa-politique-par-le-besoin-de-securite-508223.htm?utm_source=rss_feed&utm_medium=link&utm_campaign=unknown

