The German organization TÜV has just published its 2027 technical inspection report. As in previous years, Tesla is still at the bottom of the ranking. But, this year, the American manufacturer is joined by a Chinese manufacturer: MG with its MG4.
It has become a chestnut tree that Tesla’s detractors enjoy. Each end of the year, the TÜV-Verband (the federation of TÜV organizations, which carry out a large part of the technical inspections across the Rhine) takes stock of the most failed vehicles (as well as the most reliable). As in previous years, the Tesla Model 3 and Model Y are among the worst scores in the recent vehicle category.
The 2027 report, which covers the controls carried out from July 1, 2025 to June 30, 2026, has just been published on November 19, 2026 on the ADAC website. With 18.5% of counter-inspections for major defects, the Tesla Model Y once again finished last, but it was joined at the bottom of the ranking by the MG4 which showed a 16% failure rate at the first presentation of the vehicle.
As is often the case, stories of brakes
If these electric cars fail massively, it is not because their battery is failing or their engine is giving up the ghost. In any case, this is not what the technical inspection checks, whether German or French. The illness from which these models suffer is much more banal.

In the case of the MG4, German inspectors point to a major culprit: the brake discs. On more than one in ten MG4s (10.3%), the discs are reported to be defective or pitted by rust, a figure ten times higher than the average for cars of this age.
This is the great paradox of the electric car: thanks to regenerative braking, the driver no longer uses mechanical braking enough. Except that by never pinching the discs, they rust, become clogged and end up losing efficiency, to the point of failing the inspection. A fault that simple braking very hard on a fast lane from time to time would often be enough to avoid.
The lack of regular maintenance on Teslas still penalizes them
For Teslas, the problem of underused brakes adds to premature wear of the suspensions. The Model Y and Model 3 are particularly heavy and powerful vehicles, which puts a strain on ball joints and wishbones on bumpy roads. In the absence of an inspection by the manufacturer who would note this defect before passing the TÜV, many Tesla owners go directly to the technical inspection without ever having visited a brand workshop since purchasing the car.

At the technical inspection, these owners are then failed for a poorly adjusted headlight or a tired triangle, obtain the exact list of defects on the report, and return to Tesla to repair only what is necessary. This way of doing things mechanically inflates the figure of failed vehicles, the ADAC itself recognizes this, and keeps the brand at the bottom of the ranking.
However, one figure works in Tesla’s favor: the Model Ys tested had 58,000 km on average, or 11,000 km more than the average for their age class. What also weighs on the wear of the ball joints and triangles.
The customer benefits, since he saves the price of revisions. On paper, however, the brand’s statistics turn into carnage. The other electrics in the ranking, pampered by annual servicing at their dealership (like the Mazda MX-30 or the Audi Q8 e-tron), show excellent scores: 3.0% of major defects for the Mazda, third out of 109 models, and 3.2% for the Audi, fifth. The revisions undoubtedly have something to do with it, some of the defects being corrected in advance by the mechanic.
All the tech news at a glance
Add Numerama to your home screen and stay connected to the future!
An exclusive editorial, a guide, a reading summary and the editorial agenda: this is what you will find every Thursday in AlwaysPlus, the tech newsletter written by Julien Cadot. Register for free here!

