The CNIL imposed a fine of 5 million euros on a company which kept its customers’ passwords in plain text, taking care not to name it. Under his announcement on X, all it took was one question for Grok to see a name appear, already cited by the press in October.
All you had to do was ask.
This November 18, 2026, around 9:30 a.m., the CNIL published a press release entitled “Conservation of customer passwords in plain text: the CNIL imposes a sanction of 5 million euros”.
The organization then explained that it had chosen not to name the company in question, considering that its educational objective did not make it ” useful “.
Less than an hour after the ad was posted on X, a user asked Grok who it was. After an initial evasive response, the AI released the name Macif Vie, based on articles in the specialized press published in October.
Black Friday: your digital serenity at -61%
Secure your purchases during Black Friday with the best offer of the year. Find the good deals, Bitdefender takes care of the scams.
Passwords readable by any employee
Basically, CNIL checks showed that customer area passwords were stored in clear text.
They were therefore readable by anyone with access to the database, even though they should have been transformed by an irreversible hash function.
According to the deliberation, nearly 1.8 million passwords were affected. Several employees also shared the same identifiers to access customer databases, which made it impossible to know who was viewing what.
Finally, the company kept the messages in its contact form for more than 10 years, and its connection data beyond the period of one year that it had set itself. No leaks were noted, and the company corrected these deficiencies during the procedure.
A file already told in October
The fact remains that the CNIL was not required to withhold the name of the company. On its site, the organization explains that it chooses to publish its decisions by naming or not the sanctioned organization. She did it for Free in 2022 or for De Particulier à Particulier in 2024, both sanctioned for passwords stored in the clear.
This is also what his rapporteur demanded in this matter. The CNIL finally gave up, thus sparing the insurer the damage to its reputation that it feared.
Except that the damage was already very largely done. On October 15, MLex, a press agency specializing in regulatory news, revealed that during a hearing in Paris, the CNIL rapporteur had proposed a fine of 7 million euros against Macif Vie. He criticized it for not having secured its customers’ passwords and for having kept personal data longer than necessary, which corresponds to the two breaches noted by the CNIL in its press release.
Questioned by Numerama today, Macif Vie did not deny being the targeted company. The insurer indicates that it has “ took note of the CNIL’s decision » and assures that he has “ implemented all security measures, in compliance with current requirements “. He also wants to “ to reassure [ses] customers on the fact that none of their data was disclosed “.
All the tech news at a glance
Add Numerama to your home screen and stay connected to the future!

